Strathmore 400 Series
Paul Rubens Art Supplies
Winsor & Newton Professional
Ever wondered why some of your watercolor projects turn out differently than you planned? Let me give you a hot tip: It might just be your sketchbook.
But…a sketchbook is a sketchbook, right?
Wrong! I can’t even count how many times I’ve been frustrated because my “sketchbook” couldn’t handle a simple wash or started peeling. Let’s not even talk about how some pages warped so badly, they looked like they were auditioning for a roller coaster design.
Choosing a quality sketchbook is like choosing a good partner for a dance. You want something that can keep up with you, make you look good, and not fall apart halfway through the performance. Over the years, I’ve learned (sometimes the hard way) that the quality of your sketchbook or your watercolor paper is just as important (if not more) than your paints and brushes.
Not all sketchbooks are created equal, and choosing the right one can make a world of difference. This article is here to help you find the best watercolor sketchbook for you, from learning how to differentiate the types of paper, to understanding which presentation will work better for you, we’ve crafted this guide to give you the utmost help and we hope it can be a stepping stone in your artistic journey.
Let’s get started!
How to Find the Best Watercolor Sketchbook
Size
Alright, let’s start by asking the important questions. Why does size matter? Well, first off, convenience. If you’re the adventurous type, always hiking up mountains or lounging at beachside cafés, you’ll want a sketchbook that can easily slip into your bag. A pocket-sized or A5 sketchbook can be your best friend for capturing the world on the go.
But, maybe you’re a studio artist, the kind who lights a candle, puts on a lo-fi playlist, and dives deep into intricate landscapes or complex portraits. In that case, you might want something roomier, like an A4 or even an A3 sketchbook. More space means more room to let those creative juices flow and splash around.
Here’s the kicker, size also affects the paper’s behavior. Smaller pads often have sheets that can buckle or warp less than their larger counterparts, simply because there’s less surface area to manage. Larger pads, however, give you the freedom to go all out with washes and wet-on-wet techniques without worrying about running out of room.
Paper Weight
Paper weight is typically measured in grams per square meter (gsm). In the States, you might see this as pounds (lb), but it’s the same idea. The weight tells you a lot about how the paper will behave when you introduce it to water. Low gsm? You’re likely to get warping, buckling, and maybe even some tearing. High gsm? That’s when you know you’ve got a paper that can stand up to your wildest watercolor pieces.
For most watercolor works, you’ll want something that’s at least 300 gsm, this ensures that the paper is sturdy enough to handle a good amount of water without turning into a wavy mess. If you’re just doodling or practicing, you might get away with something lighter, like 200 gsm, but don’t expect it to handle heavy washes or wet-on-wet techniques.
Texture
There are different ways of making watercolor paper, depending on which method is applied, different textures form on the paper. We have three main textures, Hot-pressed which is smooth, and it allows for crazy detailed work. You can get those fine lines and details, great for botanical illustrations, tight portraits, and anything else that requires insane amounts of detail. But beware, it doesn’t hold onto water as well, so blending and washes can be a bit trickier.
Cold-pressed paper, on the other hand, is the standard for most sketchbooks, it’s got a bit of texture, which is fantastic for holding onto pigment and water. This makes blending a dream, and it’s forgiving enough for both beginners and experienced artists. If you’re unsure what to get, this is usually your safest bet.
Sizing
Let’s look into another often-overlooked aspect of choosing the perfect watercolor sketchbook: sizing. And no, we’re not talking about the dimensions of your paper again. This time, we’re discussing the protective layer that often coats quality watercolor paper, making it more resistant to water.
Sizing is a substance that’s either applied to the surface of the paper or integrated into the paper pulp during the manufacturing process. What it does is simple but crucial: it controls how much water the paper absorbs.
- External Sizing: Externally sized paper has a coating applied to the surface. This makes the paper less absorbent and helps maintain vibrancy as the pigments sit more on the surface.
- Internal Sizing: Internally-sized paper has the sizing mixed into the pulp, providing even absorption but also a quicker absorption rate.
Binding
- Spiral Bound: A favorite among students and quick sketch artists for good reason, the beauty of a spiral-bound sketchbook lies in its 360-degree page-turning ability. Want to get your previous work out of the way so you can focus on your current masterpiece? Just flip it around, and that’s it! Plus, it lays flat, so you won’t fight with a stubborn page that wants to curl up on you.
- Hardcover: A hardcover sketchbook might not be as flexible as its spiral-bound cousin, but it has certain perks. Your work feels permanent, almost archival. The drawback? They can be a bit heavier and bulkier, so they may not be the best for your backpacking-through-Europe art journey.
- Tape or Stitch Bound: Finally, there’s the tape or stitch bound, often found in more high-end or specialty sketchbooks. These are the kinds you usually can’t lay flat but have the benefit of looking extremely sleek and professional. If you’re planning an art show or want to gift someone a portfolio of your work, these could be your go-to.
Price
When it comes to sketchbooks, the price often reflects quality, but it’s essential to find that sweet spot for your needs and wallet. Bargain buys under $10 are great for practice but often compromise on paper weight and durability. Mid-range options, priced between $15-$40, offer a solid balance of quality materials suitable for both hobbyists and emerging artists. If you’re going pro or simply want the best, luxury sketchbooks can go above $50 and offer artisanal papers and high-quality bindings. The best watercolor sketchbook is a mix of what you need artistically and what you can afford.
Best Watercolor Sketchbook
- Best Watercolor Sketchbook Overall — Strathmore 400 Series.
- Best Mixed Media Watercolor Sketchbook — Holbein Multimedia Book.
- Best Budget Watercolor Sketchbook — Paul Rubens Art Supplies Watercolor Journal.
- Best Budget Watercolor Sketchbook Alternative — Arteza Watercolor Sketchbook
- Best Watercolor Sketchbook for Professional — Winsor & Newton Professional.
- Best Premium Watercolor Sketchbook — Arches Watercolor Travel Journal.
#1. Best Watercolor Sketchbook Overall — Strathmore 400 Series
Selection Criteria
- Size: 8’’ x 5.5’’ inches.
- Our Score: 8/10
- Paper Weight: 300 gsm.
- Our Score: 9/10
- Texture: Cold Pressed, Grain fin.
- Our Score: 8/10
- Sizing: Internal sizing.
- Our Score: 9/10
- Binding and number of sheets: Sewn binding and glue, 48 Pages.
- Our Score: 9/10
- Price: $25.95
- Our Score: 7/10
About the Strathmore 400 Series.
The Strathmore 400 Series stands out as the undisputed leader in the watercolor notebook category, measuring 8” x 5.5” inches and featuring an impressive 300 gsm paper weight, this notebook is a canvas in itself. The cold-pressed texture with fine grain ensures a perfect surface for watercolor but what really sets this notebook apart is its durability. With sewn and glued binding, its 48 pages stay secure even under the constant abuse of water and layers of paint, however, its “higher” price tag reflects its premium quality, which could be a dealbreaker for tighter budgets.
Pros
- High-quality paper
- Durable hardbound
- Acid-free
Cons
- Expensive
- Limited sizes
2. Best Mixed Media Watercolor Sketchbook — Holbein Multimedia Book
Selection Criteria
- Size: 9.25’’ x 6.5’’ inches
- Our Score: 8/10
- Paper Weight: 200 gsm.
- Our Score: 8/10
- Texture: Cold Pressed, Grain fin.
- Our Score: 8/10
- Sizing: Internal sizing.
- Our Score: 9/10
- Binding and number of sheets: Spiral-Bound, 28 Pages.
- Our Score: 8/10
- Price: $16.75.
- Our Score: 9/10
About the Holbein Multimedia Book.
The Holbein Multimedia Book is a versatile choice for artists exploring mixed media. Measuring 9.25” x 6.5” inches, and offering 200 gsm paper, this sketchbook is any artist’s dream. Suitable for watercolors and other mediums, its cold-pressed texture with fine grain and internal sizing make it an adaptable yet portable canvas. The 28-page spiral binding gives it flexibility but also means it has less capacity than some competitors. However, its attractive price makes it an excellent option for artists looking for quality and economy.
Pros
- Versatile paper
- Spiral-bound
- Multi-media friendly
Cons
- Costly
- Limited availability
3. Best Budget Watercolor Sketchbook— Paul Rubens Art Supplies Watercolor Journal
Selection Criteria
- Size: 7.6” x 5.3” inches.
- Our Score: 8/10
- Paper Weight:300 gsm.
- Our Score: 9/10
- Texture: Hot pressed, Satin grain.
- Our Score: 8/10
- Sizing: Internal sizing.
- Our Score: 9/10
- Binding and number of sheets: Sewn binding, 20 Pages.
- Our Score: 9/10
- Price: $14.99.
- Our Score: 9/10
About the Paul Rubens Art Supplies Watercolor Journal.
The Paul Rubens Art Supplies Watercolor Journal offers an attractive combination of quality and price, with a compact size of 7.6” x 5.3” inches, this notebook features thick and resistant 300 gsm paper, perfect for watercolors and the hot-pressed texture with satin grain adds a special touch to your work. Perfect for botanical illustrators, manga artists, and hobbyists, the sewn binding and 20 pages provide durability and enough space for smaller projects. Its price is very competitive, making it an ideal option for those looking for a quality notebook without spending too much, however, its size might be a downside for those who prefer working on large formats.
Pros
- Affordable
- Good texture
- Lightweight
Cons
- Limited durability
- Bleeds easily
4. Best Budget Watercolor Sketchbook Alternative — Arteza Watercolor Sketchbook
Selection Criteria
- Size:9’’ x 12’’’ inches.
- Our Score: 8/10
- Paper Weight: 300 gsm.
- Our Score: 9/10
- Texture: Cold Pressed, Grain fin.
- Our Score: 8/10
- Sizing: Internal sizing.
- Our Score: 9/10
- Binding and number of sheets: Spiral-Bound, 64 Pages.
- Our Score: 9/10
- Price: $16.00.
- Our Score: 8/10
About the Arteza Watercolor Sketchbook.
Arteza offers a solid affordable alternative in the world of watercolor notebooks. With a decent 9 x 12 inches size and an impressive weight of 300 gsm, this notebook offers excellent value for money. The cold-pressed texture with fine grain and internal sizing makes it a versatile work surface for watercolors and other mediums and while this sketchbook might not be made of archival paper, it’s great for practicing and casual illustration.
The 64-page spiral binding provides plenty of space for your creations, and it’s affordable and attractive to artists looking for quality without spending too much. However, keep in mind that spiral binding might be less durable compared to other binding methods.
Pros
- Cost-effective
- Versatile sizes
- Wide availability
Cons
- Inconsistent paper
- Warping possible
5. Best Watercolor Sketchbook for Professionals— Winsor & Newton Professional
Selection Criteria
- Size:5’’ x 7’’ inches.
- Our Score: 7/10
- Paper Weight: 300 gsm.
- Our Score: 9/10
- Texture: Cold Pressed, Grain fin.
- Our Score: 8/10
- Sizing: Internal sizing.
- Our Score: 9/10
- Binding and number of sheets: Spiral-Bound, 15 Pages.
- Our Score: 7/10
- Price: $18.87.
- Our Score: 8/10
About the Winsor & Newton Professional.
The Winsor & Newton Professional is a compact notebook designed specifically for professional artists. With a size of 5” x 7” inches and 300 gsm paper, this notebook offers exceptional quality for high-end projects. The cold-pressed texture with fine grain and internal sizing meets the expectations of professionals and is able to resist heavy washes and lots of water.
However, its number of pages is limited to 15, which could be insufficient for those who love working on multiple projects. At $18.87, it’s a more expensive investment per page compared to other notebooks but it’s worth it for those who want their art preserved for a very long time and for those who love quality over quantity.
Pros
- Professional-grade
- High GSM
- Long-lasting
Cons
- Expensive
- Heavier
6. Best Premium Watercolor Sketchbook — Arches Watercolor Travel Journal.
Selection Criteria
- Size: 6’’ x 10’’ inches.
- Our Score: 8/10
- Paper Weight: 300 gsm.
- Our Score: 9/10
- Texture: Cold Pressed, Grain fin.
- Our Score: 8/10
- Sizing: Internal and External sizing.
- Our Score: 9/10
- Binding and number of sheets: Spiral-Bound, 15 Pages.
- Our Score: 7/10
- Price: $29.00.
- Our Score: 7/10
About the Arches Watercolor Travel Journal.
In watercolor, Arches is the best, that’s why the Arches Watercolor Travel Journal stands out as the premium option in the world of watercolor notebooks. With a size of 6” x 10” inches and 300 gsm paper with internal and external sizing, this notebook offers the highest quality for demanding artists. The cold-pressed texture with fine grain provides an exceptional working surface for watercolors.
The spiral binding and 15 pages make it an ideal choice for artists on the go. However, its $29.00 price tag reflects its premium status, which may not suit all budgets. It is the perfect choice for those who value quality and are willing to invest in their art.
Pros
- Premium quality
- Travel-friendly
- Durable
Cons
- High cost
- Limited availability
FAQ
Q: What paper weight is recommended for watercolor sketchbooks?
A: A minimum of 140 lb (300 gsm) paperweight is generally recommended for watercolor sketchbooks. The heavier the paper, the less likely it will warp or deteriorate when wet.
Q: Can I use both sides of the paper in a watercolor sketchbook?
A: While you technically can use both sides, most artists prefer to use only one side to prevent any possible bleed-through or paper warping.
Q: Are all watercolor sketchbooks acid-free?
A: Most high-quality watercolor sketchbooks use acid-free paper to prevent yellowing and degradation over time so always check the product description to be sure.
Q: Can I use other types of media in my watercolor sketchbook?
A: While watercolor sketchbooks are optimized for water-based media, many artists use them for mixed media applications like ink, colored pencils, and gouache.
Q: How do I take care of my watercolor sketchbook?
A: Keep your watercolor sketchbook dry and clean, and avoid excessive bending or folding of the pages. Some artists also like to store their finished works in plastic sleeves for added protection.
